the home of online investigations

The Battle of Idlib Opens with the Bombing of Medical and Rescue Facilities

September 9, 2018

By Eliot Higgins

Translations: Русский

Medical and rescue facilities in opposition held areas have frequently been the target of air strikes by pro-government forces, and what appears to be the open stages of the Battle for Idlib is no different. On September 6th 2018 the Syrian Civil Defence Twitter account posted images of what was described as a White Helmets centre that had gone out of service following a massive attack on the Idlib countryside:

The damaged White Helmets Centre in Idlib (source)

On September 8th, Hass underground hospital was targeted in airstrikes, with multiple videos from the hospital shared online following the attack:

Footage shows heavy damage to the area outside the hospital entrance, including structural damage and destroyed and damaged vehicles and equipment. The interior of the hospital is shown in multiple videos, clearly showing damage to the interior of the hospital and hospital equipment. In none of the videos is their any indication of any military presence at the site.

Hala Systems, who uses an on the ground network inside Syria to track the movements of aircraft, provided data about air activity in the area around the time of attack. They tracked multiple Mi-8 Hip helicopters flying from the Vehicles School helicopter base in Hama, taking off around 40 minutes before the attack. After that, Hips were sighted by different spotters on the route towards Hass underground hospital, then around the area Hass hospital is in just before it was bombed. According to reports from Hala Systems the hospital was then bombed twice, with 10 minutes between each attack.

Mi-8 Hip helicopters are military transport helicopters, and are linked to the use of improvised barrel bombs. On the day of the Hass hospital attack a Mi-8 Hip was filmed dropping a barrel bomb on the town of Al-Lataminah, just 20km south of Hass:

The Hala System reports are consistent with witness statements about the attack and video footage filmed at the site of the attack. A video uploaded to YouTube by Orient News shows the moment the hospital was struck:

The bomb above the hospital just before it impacts and explodes (source)

The bomb is clearly visible in the air, and the noise of the bomb travelling through the air, sometimes mistaken for the sound of aircraft can also be heard, cutting off after the bomb explodes. This same audio phenomenon is captured in other videos, for example this video filmed on September 9th 2018 that shows a clearly identifiable barrel bomb producing the same noise shortly before it hits the ground:

This would strongly indicate at least one barrel bomb dropped from the helicopter was used in the attack, consistent with other statements. In the following video (translation here), one witness describes helicopters dropping barrel bombs on the hospital:

Other witnesses state the hospital was attacked twice by helicopters dropping barrel bombs, first the entrance to the hospital was hit, followed by a second attack that destroyed power generators. Initial reports from the attack indicate 3 people were injured in the bombing, two visitors and an anesthesia technician.

In addition to medical and rescue facilities being targeted by air strikes, footage uploaded to YouTube by The White Helmets in Idlib on September 9th 2018 shows members of The White Helmets putting out a fire in Khan Sheikhoun, a target of heavy bombardment in the last few days, being bombed by what’s claimed to be cluster munitions:

The Union of Medical Care & Relief Organizations (UOSSM) published a statement describing six medical and civilian facilities have been attacked in the last two days in Idlib, which included “[t]hree hospitals, two Syrian Civil Defense Centers, and an ambulance system”. This targeting of medical and civilian facilities has become a familiar strategy for pro-government forces before any major offensive in Syria, and will almost certainly be followed up with more attacks on medical and civilian facilities.

 

Bellingcat’s research for this publication was supported by PAX for Peace.

Eliot Higgins

Eliot Higgins is the founder of Bellingcat and the Brown Moses Blog. Eliot focuses on the weapons used in the conflict in Syria, and open source investigation tools and techniques.

Join the Bellingcat Mailing List:

Enter your email address to receive a weekly digest of Bellingcat posts, links to open source research articles, and more.

Support Bellingcat

You can support the work of Bellingcat by donating through the below link:

53 Comments

  1. JOHN CHUCKMAN

    I’ve never looked at your publication before, and I was curious.

    It is a nice-looking publication.

    But good God, the content ranks right down there with Theresa May speeches or Thomas Friedman columns.

    What obvious and unconvincing propaganda.

    You intersperse it with other stuff, like aerial photo interpretation, to give the appearance of wider interests and expertise.

    But that’s all just to dilute the venom, so it doesn’t come across like Pravda in 1957.

    Reply
  2. Игорь Чалый

    Fake maker continue to make fakes. We see white helmets the payed men who provide fake avidances. In fact those people are going to stage a chemical atak on Idlib to help ISIS and their allays USA to escape fair punishment.

    Reply
  3. Rob Heusdens

    What is the proof that those so-called “medical” facilities were not in fact Al Nusra’s military command post? The terrorists have been using such infrastructure (like schools, hospitals) for military usage troughout the conflict.
    Very cheap form of propaganda again, brought by Al Qaeda/Al Nusra, echoed by Bellingcat – NATO’s sponsoring of terrorism….

    Reply
  4. Mr propaganda watch

    remember when they said the same thing about alleppo? and that assad is a monster etc etc…..well the ordinary civilian was over joyed to see terror proxies gone. Life returned to normal .not like sharia law enforcing terrorists were liked or wanted . Most people in syria fleeing war flee to the government side. I mean with our secular western values why on earth do you people support terrorists . You should be supporting law and order ,freedom of choice and life over death. In other words assad is the good guy here he is doing his job………which is to defend his country.

    Reply
    • Alex

      Assad is the good guy!! Yes, just like Putin is a good guy!! Mugabe is a good guy and Qaddafi was a good guy and every despot murdering scumbag is a “good guy”.

      Next you will tell us that Tony B Liar and George Bush, the two good guys responsible for the murder of hundreds of thousands of innocent men, women, children and babies in Iraq, were also your “good guys”.

      Reply

Leave a Reply to HRIMark

  • (will not be published)