the home of online investigations

Videos and Photographs Claim to Show Civilians Killed by US Led Air Strikes in Syria

September 23, 2014

By Eliot Higgins

Following last night’s air strikes on targets inside Syria by US led forces, a number of claims were made about civilian victims of the air strikes. After 3 years of conflict Syrian opposition groups have already established social media networks that have allowed them to quickly share and disseminate images and reports from the conflict, and this has meant it’s been possible to find evidence to support the claims of US led air strikes killing and injuring civilians.

The main allegations come from the small town of Kafar Deryan, in Idlib, and west of Aleppo, where videos and images posted to social media channels have shown rescue efforts after the attacks, victims, and the debris of the munition used.

Reports on the local Facebook page posted around midday details 4 dead and 8 wounded, and includes images of the victims

1 Child Zainab Muhanna Barakat
2 Child Safaa’ Muhanna Barakat
3 Child Mahmoud Juma’a Muaz
4 Mother of Mahmoud Juma’a Muaz

The names of the wounded
1 Khansa Juma’a al-Doush
2 Child Ahmad Muhanna Barakat
3 Child Malak Muhanna Barakat
4 Sabha Shaker Taher, Wife of Muhanna Barakat
5 Child girl Wafaa’ Muhanna Barakat
6 Child Mahmoud Mohammed Muaz
7 Safwan Yahya Skaff
8 Juma’a Mahmoud Muaz

It also reported 3 women and 3 children were killed who they had not yet identified.

A post a few hours later lists four more dead

1 Abdul Hamid Muhammad Jahjah.
2 His wife Reem Al-Hajji.
3 His daughter Basmalah Jahjah.
4 His son Mohammed Jahjah.

In both reports the deaths and injures are linked to US led air strikes.

Videos of the rescue efforts were posted on the local YouTube channel, as well as on their Facebook page

A video was also posted on their YouTube channel claiming to show the air strikes as they happened, including multiple strikes

Video from the next day shows the destruction done to buildings in the area

Several videos and photographs also show the remains of the munitions used (captions from the original image shared here)

ByOf0aZIcAAkdU1 ByOfyP5IYAE91h0 ByOfz52IQAE_bFY

 

The remains do not match any munition seen in the conflict so far, and a number of specialists have told me these may by the remains of a Tomahawk missile, although due to the heavy damage to the munitions it’s currently not possible to be certain. The strike location would also be in the areas defined by today’s Pentagon press conference on the air strikes

ByOhmjTCUAAHvbd

It seems, based on this information, that there’s strong evidence that US led air strikes led to the deaths of 11-14 civilians, if local reports are accurate, along with a further 8 being injured in last nights air strikes.

Updates Recent posts by Jabhat al-Nusra linked Twitter implies a presence in the town, with this tweet claiming their HQ in the town was empty and only civilians were kiled. However, the administrator of the Facebook page has denied any JaN or ISIS HQs in the town after we contacted them. Another contact in the town claimed that all of the Jabhat al-Nusra HQs are located on the edge of the town, not inside it, and they had already been emptied of fighters and equipment before the attack. He also claimed all the missiles hit civilian homes and nearly all the victims were civilians. He went on to add

We think the strikes targeted Abu Yousef al-Turki, a prominent trainer on the use of sniper rifles. The nearest JaN HQ is 100 meters away from the town. JaN prevented anyone from approaching their HQs after the attack, so nobody knows exactly how many were killed and injured. However, we are quite certain that a number of JaN fighters were killed in the attack

Eliot Higgins

Eliot Higgins is the founder of Bellingcat and the Brown Moses Blog. Eliot focuses on the weapons used in the conflict in Syria, and open source investigation tools and techniques.

Join the Bellingcat Mailing List:

Enter your email address to receive a weekly digest of Bellingcat posts, links to open source research articles, and more.

Support Bellingcat

You can support the work of Bellingcat by donating through the below link:

4 Comments

  1. Rukasu

    What of the bus allegedly hit in Abu Kamal?
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n5WGT520r2M

    Got posted heavy earlier today, even picked up by the LCC’s, where someone claimed it was older, https://www.facebook.com/LCCSy/posts/995001707193632, but can’t find earlier examples of video. Reverse thumbnail and Amnesty verification site yield nothing older than today.

    Uploader’s first video in four months, so a little suspicious. Plus, damage to bus looks of bullet holes, not missile.

    Reply
  2. alan taylor

    err… so is this website going to list all the names of people who have died in Syria?

    Or just those killed by Coalition air strikes?

    Reply
  3. jodywave

    Missile remnants; Looks like the guts of a severely damaged Teledyne CAE J402-CA-100 Turbojet motor or something very similar. Additionally, there should be lots of components from severely damaged Williams International F107-WR-402 and/or F415-WR-400/402 Turbofan motors around certain impact areas. Don’t be surprised if someone finds a mostly intact weapon that these motors propel because there probably are a few dudes somewhere out there in the desert/mountains of Syria.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

  • (will not be published)