the home of online investigations

You can support the work of Bellingcat by donating through the following link:

Identifying The Berlin Bicycle Assassin Part 1 – From Moscow to Berlin

December 3, 2019

By Bellingcat Investigation Team

  • In its previous joint investigations with Spiegel, The Insider and Dossier Center, Bellingcat has reported that the person held by German authorities over the murder of Zelimkhan Khangoshvili in Berlin traveled from Moscow to Germany under a fake identity.
  • We established that the suspected assassin’s passport, issued under the name Vadim Sokolov, born 20 August 1970, was issued to a non-existing persona. We identified that the earliest reference to that identity in Russian registries was in September 2015 when this “person” received his first domestic passport, aged 45. “Vadim Sokolov” was assigned a tax identification number only in July 2019, days before applying for his Schengen visa on which he traveled to Paris, Warsaw, and then to Berlin.
  • We concluded that the issuance of valid domestic passport, tax ID and a international travel passport to a non-existing persona could not have happened without the direct involvement of the Russian state, and thus implicates Russian security services in the assassination in Berlin.
  • Spiegel reported on Tuesday that the Federal General Prosecutor Peter Frank has reached a conclusion that the Russian authorities likely ordered the Berlin murder. As a result, the Federal Prosecutor’s office is expected to take over the case from the Berlin investigative office in the next few days.
  • Spiegel also reports that the German authorities were able to identify the true identity of the killer through matching him to a Russian citizen previously wanted by the Russian state on an Interpol red notice, which however was later withdrawn. That person had been wanted over the murder of a Russian businessman in 2013.

Independently from the findings of the German authorities, our investigative team has independently verified that the real identity of the Berlin assassin who traveled under the fake identity of Vadim Sokolov is in fact Vadim Nikolaevich Krasikov. Vadim Krasikov was born on 10 August 1965, and not in 1970 as per his cover identity. In 19 June 2013, Krasikov was the key suspect in the murder a Russian businessman who had been the subject of several previous assassination attempts. The murder in Moscow was similar in many respects to the Berlin assassination – the killer had approached his target on a bicycle, had shot at him with a hand gun at close range, both in the back and in the head, and had left on his bike.

Russian authorities were able to identity the suspect using a description from an incidental witness, and video footage from parking lot security cameras that had captured the murder. In early 2014, Russia initiated a national and international search for the suspect – who they identified as Vadim Krasikov. An Interpol warrant was also issued by Moscow. However, just over a year later, in July 2015, the Interpol notice and national search warrants were withdrawn, implying that the suspect had been detained, or alternatively no longer a suspect in the crime. The criminal investigation into the Moscow murder itself has not been closed and no other suspects have been named.

Airline booking data reviewed by Bellingcat shows that a year after the termination of his search warrant, Krasikov resumed air travel across Russia, with multiple trips to occupied Crimea and even to a neighboring Central Asian country. This is further evidence that at that point in time Krasikov was no longer wanted by Russian authorities, who would have been aware of his travels, including border crossings.

In the meantime, nearly all records of the existence of the suspect Vadim Krasikov has been purged from Russian state databases. A criminal case file in his name does not exist in the central police database, despite multiple references to the crime and his role as a wanted suspect remain in archived databases reviewed by us. There are no current records of driver’s licenses held by this person while, again, older archived data sources show that he did own a car and had a driver’s permit. No entry exists for Krasikov in the social insurance contributions database. The only proof of his existence is a valid passport in his name in Russia’s central passport database.

Left, “Vadim Sokolov”‘s photograph from his Schengen visa application. Right, a colourised archived photograph from Vadim Krasikov’s driver’s license. Face comparison made with Microsoft’s Azure facial recognition software shows a match with a very high confidence factor.

The fact that Krasikov’s search warrant was silently withdrawn, the purging of data in relation to Krasikov – including to any criminal proceedings involving him – from current Russian databases, as well as the fabrication of a full set of parallel data for a non-existing persona confirms our earlier conclusion that the Berlin assassination was a state-sponsored act. The alternative hypothesis of an organized crime project is contradicted by a set of wide-ranging, consistent administrative interventions that could only be implemented by a state actor.

The Moscow Murder

In the wee hours of 19 June 2013, an entrepreneur from Russia’s North Caucuses republic Kabardino-Balkaria was parking his car at a lot near his Moscow apartment. Albert Nazranov, who owned a restaurant chain and the central marketplace in the region’s capital Nalchik, had been the target of several assassination attempts, including an improvised explosive device that went off during his morning run just eight months prior. Thus he became wary when a man wearing an unseasonable hat approached him on a bicycle just after he locked his car. Nazranov tried to preemptively attack the assailant, managed to push him off the bike and started running away. The cyclist, pulling out a Makarov gun, caught up with Nazranov, and after a short chase and an initial misfire, was able to fire five bullets into the victim, with one shot in the chest and another in the head, both at close range.

The murder was caught on the parking lot’s security cameras and was broadcast by several Russian TV channels later that day.

After an initial flurry of news coverage of the blatant bicycle murder in the summer of 2013, no further news of the investigation into the case found its way to Russian media. The last news reference to the murder quotes a law enforcement source who said that the murder was a contract killing and that police has launched a search for a “slim man of average height wearing a hat“.

Our review of previously leaked databases containing crime and search warrant data show that on 29 January 2014, Russian police launched a nation-wide search for Vadim Krasikov in relation to a murder committed on 19 June 2013. The measure sought by the police was “arrest”. The archived data also shows that the search warrant was terminated on 26 June 2015 via “circular decision 349/2015”. The record also shows that the information about the search termination was entered into IBD (an integrated database of the Russian police showing each resident’s prior criminal history, including initiation and termination of any criminal proceedings) on 15 July 2015.

Several sources with access to Russia’s IBD database have confirmed to us that as of this moment, no entry for Vadim Krasikov exists. The circular decision referenced in the archived data can also not be found. This is highly unusual and implies that his entry was purged post factum, as a record for Krasikov would need to exist in the IBD system even if he would have been fully exonerated, or his status of suspect had been reversed.

Shortly after the federal search warrant was issued by Russian police, Russia filed an international “red notice” search warrant with Interpol. Three European police sources from different countries have confirmed to us that an international arrest warrant was entered by Interpol’s Moscow office in 2014, but was revoked in 2015. The photograph submitted by Russia to Interpol in 2014 shows a definitive match to the face of the Berlin assassination suspect “Vadim Sokolov”.

Left, Vadim Krasikov’s photo as provided by Russian authorities to Interpol in 2014. Right, “Vadim Sokolov” visa application photo 2019

There has been no further public information on the status of investigation into the June 2013 Moscow murder. A search in Moscow court databases for the criminal case file listed in the initial (archived) Russian search notice does not yield any results.

Who is Vadim Krasikov

Vadim Nikolaevich Krasikov was born on 10 August 1965 in the town of Kenes-Tobe in the southernmost area of (then) Soviet Kazakhstan. In the 80s his family relocated to Buryatia, a mountanus region in Eastern Siberia, close to the border with Mongolia. In the late 80’s Krasikov got married and had two children before relocating to the southern Siberian city of Irkutsk.

He remarried and settled in a small town near Moscow in 2009. Bellingcat and its partners are still investigating his actual activities during the period prior to the Moscow murder, as well as his possible linkage to military or security services before or after the assassination in Moscow.

 

More details on Vadim Krasikov’s activities in the period between the 2013 murder and his re-emergence in Berlin in 2019, as well as details on the state support structure that enabled his trip to Berlin will be published in Part 2 of this investigation.

 

Legal Implications

The findings that the Russian state terminated domestic and international search warrants for Vadim Krasikov, and then facilitated the issuance of a new, false identity to the same person, provides further convincing evidence that the Russian state was involved in the planning and facilitation, if not gave the mandate for the assassination of a foreign citizen on German territory. Furthermore, Russia has failed to provide information on the actual identity of the suspect detained by German police following the murder, despite Germany’s request. It is implausible that Russian investigative authorities would have been unable to immediately identify the person based in the photographs and fingerprint data normally provided by the German authorities under mutual legal assistance procedures. Even if the suspect’s fingerprints had not been stored in Russia’s central database – which would improbably imply he was never captured before his warrant was revoked – a reverse face image search using Russia’s police comprehensive SORM system would have provided an immediate match. By all public accounts, Russia has failed to provide this information to the Berlin authorities.

If Germany’s Federal Prosecutor’s Office indeed takes over the case from the Berlin office, this would be a direct recognition that Germany’s investigative authorities no longer treat this crime as a regular criminal offense. Under German criminal procedure, such an escalation would be exceptional – under a procedure of besondere Bedeutung which would be applicable either in the case of terrorism or in the case of a state-actor involvement. Based on reports in the German press, the latter conclusion has been reached by the Federal Prosecutor.

In turn, a recognition of state involvement would result in an unprecedented case of Russian authorities being accused of carrying out an extraterritorial – and by definition political – assassination on German soil. From a legal and diplomatic context, this case would then be nearly identical to the Skripals/Sturgess novichok poisoning case last year, which resulted in mass expulsions of Russian diplomats from EU and partner NATO countries.

Given Germany’s more pragmatic and moderate position vis-a-vis Moscow, underpinned by joint energy projects, a firm reaction from Berlin including diplomatic and economic sanctions is more difficult to anticipate. Yet, for those same reasons, such reaction would have much larger geopolitical implications, both outside and within Russia.

Bellingcat Investigation Team

The Bellingcat Investigation Team is an award winning group of volunteers and full time investigators who make up the core of the Bellingcat's investigative efforts.

Join the Bellingcat Mailing List:

Enter your email address to receive a weekly digest of Bellingcat posts, links to open source research articles, and more.

37 Comments

  1. Servus

    Congratulations, great job.
    So, one can enter GRU based on practical professional experience in addition to traditional military career, a sign of modernity?
    Now search for aborted criminal procedures and search warrants will identify next batch of killer « zombies ».

    Reply
  2. Fishmanxxx

    I read first an article in the Guardian and knew in the first paragraph that bellingcat would have an answer and of course you did. Excellent work as always!!

    Reply
  3. Jeroen

    Thank you Der Spiegel, Insider, Dossier Center and Bellingcat for this important reporting and brave journalism.

    Reply
  4. Amused

    what bold fantasies in the last two paragraphs 🙂
    are you dreaming of World War 3?
    PS Servant, how do you know it’s GRU and not FSB – YOU wrote this story :)??????

    Reply
    • Richard

      So you think foreign countries (or perhaps only Russia and Syria) should be immune to prosecution when they send assassination squads to Europe or America. The list of “suspicious” deaths of the enemies of Putin and Assad fills books. Should everyone else just stand by?
      Interesting that in Germany the SPD has new leadership. Both the CDU and the conservative site of the SPD are thoroughly “Schröderized”, but a new leadership may have a different opinion towards political assassination.

      Reply
      • Amused

        Dear Gerhard 🙂
        for now these are suspicions, circumstantial evidence and interpretations – nothing has been proven yet – as in the case of Skripal.
        Well, unless you know the second part of the report 🙂 so you are ahead of the game.

        Reply
        • Gerhard

          Dear M,

          This is Gerhard — Bellingcat is kind enough to offer such analysis to enlighten the public, but Western intelligence has already long ago come to its own conclusion about Russian assassinations, so you can sit back and enjoy how a post-Trump US administration along with an Erdogan-free NATO handles the cowardly, fetid, disintegrating neo-Russian Empire going forward. What other nation on earth, as a matter of fact, would order such assassinations overseas and continue to deny them, except a furtive and cowardly Russian administration? If your chief midget Putin and your compatriots were as proud and confident of your standing as you say, you wouldn’t hide behind such coy and fragile denials.

          Reply
    • Servus

      Oh… I’m sorry, I know, there is a competition between the services and , yes, thanks for correcting, it’s FSB if that makes you happy, credit where credit’s due.

      You have to learn a bit from Mr Trump, this assassination is just a hearsay because people heard what the German prosecutor said.

      Mr Assad can also teach you something, talking about Douma chemical attack, your suggested mentor said “It’s either jihadists or it did not happen at all”.

      So, be so nice and say loud “It’s CIA/MI6/DGSE/Mossad/Al Kaida or it did not happen at all”.

      Reply
      • Frank

        Where did Mr Trump say this assassination was “hearsay”? I’ve been googling and can’t find such a quote. and would he be commenting on a 2013 GRU/FSB assassination that occurred while Mr Obama was president?

        And when it comes to chemical weapons and Syria, what happened with Obama’s “red line”?

        Reply
        • Servus

          Frank,
          There are so many nice FB places, go and have fun, you are wasting your talent in here on discussions a little bit too complicated for you.

          But your attempted diversion is appriciated, the situation is truly desperate for you so anything should be attempted

          Reply
      • Amused

        Servant, I did not consider that your attitude towards GRU is almost erotic 🙂
        GRU is a fetish you. I forgot abaout it , sorry.

        Reply
    • Servus

      Masha,
      there is no contradiction, Kadyrov as instigator with support of the FSB (sorry again for the GRU) .

      I was wondering what on earth could they come up with in such a clear cut case.
      The guy caught with the smoking gun, with “real but false” identity papers, present in the Interpol database, possibly even with finger prints.

      So, take my word, soon you will be saying : “It’s CIA/MI6/DGSE/Mossad/Al Kaida or it did not happen at all”.

      Reply
  5. Henrik

    If the cases were about South America, we would not be really surprised if a criminal organisation was able to both remove a search and give new identity by using their network, using blackmail and threats. So maybe it is wise to at least keep this possibility slightly open for Russia.

    Reply
  6. Gerhard

    Congratulations to German authorities for expelling these vermin..it’s about time for direct accountability for the criminal Russian mafia regime. Eventually after all of this each and every identifiable Russia-connected individual breathing in a Western country will rightfully be under tight surveillance by security services, just as Westerners are monitored in Russia. How much longer will this go on before there is open [deniable] retaliation?

    Reply
    • Jeroen

      Russia will either deny, or they will try to capture some german ngo worker (or by syrian proxies) acuse him/her from spying and seek a prisoners exchange.

      Reply
    • Amused

      Announcement that 2 Russian diplomats are personae non gratae ( which will certainly result in the expulsion of 2 Germans from Russia), you considere this
      so groundbreaking / sensational circumstance 🙂 – in your mind it is the beginning of the revolution 🙂 the beginning of the end of the current balance of power 🙂

      You have amazing imagination Minion.

      Reply
      • Gerhard

        No, when I see “illegal” Russians disappearing from the streets of Western cities along with increasingly aggressive “accidental” overflights of Russian territory I will know the beginning of the revolution has begun.

        Reply
    • Servus

      Expulsion of the two “diplomats” (most likely identified as a part of the assassination support team) is just just a cold zakuski.
      A German MP P. Sensburg said that more expulsions or freeze of common project can be expected if Russia does not co-operate in this investigation. The German interior minister said that the government discusses the next steps.
      What will happen, Russians are not likely to expel German diplomats at this stage but will not cooperate, so more Russians will be expelled (these are warm zakuski). The main course is obvious, freezing the North Stream project.

      Putin will not like that and an FSB general will accidentally die, choking on a chicken bone. Just like the GRU boss that just suddenly faded away…

      I really hope that German politicians wake up and realize that North Stream project or any larger size project with Russia is simply personally dangerous to them and their families. Russian state gangsters kill people opposing their will. While one will need to negotiate contracts, prices, extensions, some new conditions, one can not have a normal business relations with a state ready to send killers to murder in any European capital or city.

      Reply
      • M

        There will be some noise, confusion, a light scandal etc. and then the smoke will settle down and the Germans will continue to heat up with Russian gas.

        Reply

Leave a Reply

  • (will not be published)

You can support the work of Bellingcat by donating through the following link:

TRUST IN JOURNALISM - IMPRESS