the home of online investigations

Geolocation and a Philosopher’s Stone in Kashmir

March 4, 2019

By Timmi Allen

Translations: Русский

On February 27 of this year, a MiG-21 Bison aircraft of the Indian Air Force was shot down over the contested Kashmir region of Pakistan. Soon afterward, pictures and videos showing the wreck of an Indian MiG-21 Bison at various locations were published across both traditional and social media. Bellingcat initially reported on this incident on March 2 — and took into account the associated war of words between involved parties.

The exact crash location of the MiG-21 was, however, not widely known until now. Most comments about the crash location pointed to the Samahni district in the Kashmir region; however, this is a relatively inexact location. We can assume that the MiG-21 debris is distributed in a larger area.

Two photographs have been widely distributed that show an area in which a large part of the debris (front) of the MiG crashed.

From these two photographs, we can create a panorama to make studying the area easier for conducting geolocation. This can be done by just patching together the two images in image editing software at the intersection points between the two photographs.

Additional images from social networks showed the same place from different perspectives.

Although several videos of the scene can be found across social networks, the exact location was still difficult to determine as there are no visible unique buildings or man-made structures — except for just one house in the distance — that allow for an easy geolocation.

One of the best details visible in the published images are the trees on the mountainside. While it would eventually yield a result, spending hours looking at every patch of vegetation on the hills of Kashmir across several hundred square kilometers is not a very good method.

For this reason, further information was sought that would allow for a better spatial determination and a clue of where to focus our search. In finding and watching a video in which an eyewitness was questioned, the golden clue was provided. In this video, a reporter asks the eyewitness, a man named Mohammad Yasin, where they are, to which he answers “Horran Kotla.”

Toponyms, especially in relatively remote locations, can be very difficult to find in online mapping services due to transliteration errors and local usage differences. For example, searching “Horran Kotla” in Google refers you to the Indian village of Kotla Heran, as Google attempted to “correct” any transliteration differences to no success. However, a further search for “Horran Kotla” returned a hit in Mapcarta with a location near the reported crash site in the Kashmir region.

With this delimitation of the area, the search could be intensified. A key feature that can also be cross-referenced in satellite imagery is visible in the panorama: two larger boulders amongst the vegetation.

After trial-and-error searches on Google Earth in this area, we find these two boulders, as well as the arrangement of the trees in the scene, leading to the location of this crash site: 33°13’28.9 “N 73°57’53.3 “E.

Important tip: When using Google Earth, you should turn on the “Terrain” feature (bottom-left part of the interface) to cross-reference the hills, valleys, and mountains as they appear in your source material.

Thus, even a remote area with few identifying markers can eventually be geolocated.

Timmi Allen

Timm Allen is a freelance 3D graphic artist and lives in Berlin (Germany). His focus is on the image and video analysis and creating new methods of analysis.

Join the Bellingcat Mailing List:

Enter your email address to receive a weekly digest of Bellingcat posts, links to open source research articles, and more.

Support Bellingcat

You can support the work of Bellingcat by donating through the below link:

16 Comments

  1. jj

    Clear evidence of the location of the downed I.A.F jet.Good work.
    Hope we don’t start a war of words as in the MIG 21 v F16.

    Reply
  2. Suresh

    You completely ignored the fact that the Mig took on & shot down a F-16 before she went down to engine flameout / ground fire.

    Reply
    • Hamza

      LOL…where are proofs of your claim that Mig21 shot down F16 ?

      All indian propaganda was exposed by Bellingcat in other thread..

      Reply
    • Basch

      Sure!!! and IAF won the Battle of Britain in WW2 and also dropped the two atomic bombs on Japan……

      Reply
  3. nav

    also you missed JF17 downed SU30 and couply of days the shooting video will be released. we have given one proof so far….other pilot we captured has reportedly expired later in hospital …India is not claiming him so we are not bothered to hand his body over to them. …so far two Indian jets downed with proofs….Indians claims terrorists camps attacked 300 killed ….F16 downed no photo no proof….world is not stupid.

    Reply
  4. Timmi Allen

    Your link shows the crash site of an Indian MI-17 helicopter. Not JJF17 and not SU 30. Where is the video evidence of your claim?

    Reply
  5. jj

    unbelievable that is a helicopter in the video,not a plane.Any one can see that.

    Fake news and propaganda.
    Must have been trained by the Russians.

    Reply
  6. manoj

    1) Well u managed to kill 2 of ur pilots. Poor Sods… lynched by jehadis. 2) When the Yankees come checking inventory of F 16’s the cat will be out of the bag. 2 cats actually ..1 Less F 16 and 3 to 5 less AMRAAM’s. 3) ur lying Gen Gafoor said they have 1 pilot captured ( abhi) , 1 in hospital and 1 on the run. Come on show us the 1 in hospital ( and now under 2 feet of mud) and the 2nd Indian jet u guys shot down.

    Reply
  7. Montana

    The reality is quite different to what India scripted for its population and the world. Funnily enough, all 4 of the air-to-air-missiles of the shot down Indian MiG-21 Bison have been recovered and displayed for analysts and observers: https://bit.ly/2FsQ6mD

    None of the missiles were fired by the Indian pilot Wing Commander Abhinandan Varthaman, who is credited by his government and air force with an “F-16D kill”, during the aerial engagement with Pakistani fighters. If the MiG’s missiles were used, they would’ve been shattered to smithereens – which they’re clearly not.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

  • (will not be published)